Determine the essential components of the course
If you identify the essential outcomes you can expect all students in your course to demonstrate, you can fairly evaluate all students and not have to worry about "watering down" the course.
Essential components defined
Essential components are the outcomes (including skills, knowledge, and attitudes) all students must demonstrate with or without using accommodations to be evaluated in a nondiscriminatory manner. In other words, some students might use accommodations and some might not, but all students must achieve the same outcomes. Process is important, of course, but not necessarily essential. Focusing on your course outcomes will help you to define your course's essential components.
The difference between essential and nonessential course components is similar to the difference between "essential" and "preferred" skills commonly listed in job descriptions. As an employer, you may want to see both sets of skills, but only the essential skills are an absolute requirement of employment. Similarly, in your courses, you can articulate essential outcomes that all students must demonstrate in order to successfully complete the course, as well as preferred outcomes you hope students will be able to demonstrate.
Finally, consider allowing some flexibility in getting to the outcomes. For example, a student who has the use of only one hand may still give a patient an injection, although he might need to use different procedures to achieve this outcome. Or, a student with a panic disorder may be unable to give a class presentation but may give the presentation privately to the instructor. The accommodation in this example is the private nature of the presentation; the essential component, the presentation, remains.
FAQs about essential components
How can I determine the essential components of my course?
Why is it important to define my course’s essential components?
If I provide accommodations for some students, won’t I end up watering down my course?
If I provide accommodations for some students, won’t I be giving them an unfair advantage?
Do students receive accommodations other than in a classroom setting?
Information in the "essential components" section draws on the following sources:
Anderson, P.L. (1999). Developing Essential Components and Technical Standards. Presentation at AHEAD Regional Training Workshops. Chanhassen, MN.
Blacklock, B. (1999). Handout. Considerations in Determining Essential Course/Program Requirements. University of Minnesota.
Harvard University’s Essential Components of Courses and Curriculum Scott, S. (1997).
Accommodating College Students with Learning Disabilities: How Much is Enough? Innovative Higher Education, 22, 85-99.
Scott, S. (1994). Determining Reasonable Academic Adjustments for College Students with Disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 27, 403-412.
Scott, S. (1990). Coming to Terms with the "Otherwise Qualified" Student with a Learning Disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 398-405.